FREE EXPRESS POST ACROSS AUSTRALIA · WORLDWIDE SHIPPING AVAILABLE
Privacy First logoPRIVACY FIRSTPUTTING YOUR PRIVACY FIRST.

MESSAGING

Signal vs Telegram vs WhatsApp vs Threema: Which Messaging App Is Actually Private?

Published 30 October 2026

Two smartphones with lit screens standing on a dark table

"Encrypted" is on every messaging app's homepage, but it means very different things. Some apps encrypt every message so that only you and the other person can read it. Others encrypt messages only between you and their servers, where the company can read them. And almost all of them collect some metadata: who you talk to, when, and from where.

Here's how the most popular options really compare.

The quick comparison

SignalThreemaWhatsAppTelegram
End-to-end encrypted by default✅ Everything✅ Everything✅ Messages and calls❌ Only "Secret Chats"
Group chats end-to-end encrypted✅✅✅❌
Phone number needed to sign upYes (can be hidden with a username)No (random ID)YesYes
Collects metadataMinimalMinimalYes (Meta)Yes (stored on Telegram's servers)
Owned byNon-profit foundationSwiss company (owned by German investor Comitis Capital)MetaTelegram (private company)
Open source✅✅ apps❌Apps only
CostFreeOne-off feeFreeFree

Telegram: the most misunderstood app

Telegram is not end-to-end encrypted by default. Normal chats, and all group chats and channels, are "cloud chats". They're encrypted on the way to Telegram's servers but stored there in a form Telegram can access, which is how your history syncs to every device.

Only Secret Chats are end-to-end encrypted, and they come with limits:

Telegram also uses its own encryption design (MTProto) instead of the widely studied Signal Protocol, and since September 2024 its privacy policy says that if it receives a valid order from judicial authorities confirming you're a suspect in a criminal case, it may disclose your IP address and phone number to them.

Tip: if you use Telegram, treat normal chats and groups as not private. Use Secret Chats for anything sensitive, or better, move those conversations to Signal or Threema. More detail: Is Telegram encrypted?

WhatsApp: encrypted messages, but Meta sees the rest

WhatsApp uses the same strong encryption design as Signal, so the contents of your messages and calls are end-to-end encrypted. But WhatsApp is owned by Meta (Facebook, Instagram), which collects metadata: who you message, when, how often, your phone number, contacts (if you allow it) and device information.

Tips:

Signal: the privacy benchmark

Signal is run by a non-profit and encrypts everything end to end by default: messages, groups, voice and video calls. It's designed to keep as little metadata as possible, and its encryption design is the industry standard that WhatsApp and others copied.

The main drawback is that you need a phone number to register. You can hide it from other people with a Signal username, but Signal still has it.

Tips: set a username and check that Settings → Privacy → Phone Number → "Who can see my number" is set to Nobody (Signal made this the default in 2024). Turn on Registration Lock with a PIN so nobody can take over your account with a SIM swap (see SIM swap scams in Australia).

Threema: no phone number at all

Threema, made by a Swiss company, is the strongest choice if you don't want to tie your messenger to your identity. You sign up with a random Threema ID, with no phone number or email required. Everything is end-to-end encrypted, the apps are open source, and it keeps minimal metadata.

The trade-offs: it's a one-off paid app, and fewer people use it, so you may need to bring your contacts across.

Other apps, briefly

Which should you use?

The app is only half of it

The most secure messenger can't protect you if the phone itself is compromised by spyware, a stolen unlocked device, or apps that read your screen or notifications. Pair a private messenger with a secure phone: see our phone privacy checklist and how to check your phone for spyware.

The Privacy First 10a runs GrapheneOS with our custom Security Suite and comes with a Threema licence included.

Disclosure: Privacy First sells Threema licence keys. This comparison is based on each app's publicly documented features.

Get a Threema licence→